I was reflecting recently that, in education, the client is not always right. When parents and stakeholders demand certain things of an education system, they are often at cross-purposes. For example, stakeholders such as businesses might inadvertently (or not-so-inadvertently) demand students that are overtrained and will be underpaid. Parents, of course, want their children to […]
Over the last few years, I’ve been exposed to many education debates. These debates have been about whether ‘holistic education’ is a viable educational concept, what an education ought to consist of, how educational results should be interpreted, how educational reform should be carried out and what its objectives should be, and many other related
The Core of Education Read More »
It is a sad but enduring truth that sometimes some people think of a concept and then espouse it without considering the concomitant problems. One of those concepts is holism, or an holistic education (which is one of the many kinds of holism on sale these days). In several of my previous posts, I have
The previous post was a basic analysis of why systems of mass education always lead to mass complaints. John Gatto calls such systems ‘weapons of mass instruction’. This post is about the real situation that some think is a problem. The point is not that such systems are bad, but that even if the system
Complaining about Systems of Education (Part 2) Read More »
As the population density rises, the habit of complaining about the system of education also rises. This is silly, but also unavoidable given the essential silliness of human nature. Let me explain. In ancient Greece, the concept of paideia was used to indicate ‘the art of bringing up children’ (from paidion, ‘a child’, genderless noun).
Complaining about Systems of Education (Part 1) Read More »
Over the last few years, I’ve been on a steady diet of books like Tyack & Cuban’s Tinkering Toward Utopia: A Century of Public School Reform (Harvard, 1995) and its precursor work, Tyack’s 1974 opus The One Best System: A History of American Urban Education, Low & Johnston’s Singapore Inc.: Public Policy Options in the
Modern Education: The One Best/Worst System Read More »